Body-Worn Camera may Not be the Final Verdict

  • 0

Body-Worn Camera may Not be the Final Verdict

The idea is building that once every cop is equipped with a body camera, the controversy will be taken out of police shootings and other uses of force because “what really happened” will be captured on video for all to see. Body cameras are an increasingly necessary tool for transparency. But police departments still need to do more to improve transparency and accountability.

There’s no doubt that body cameras like dash cams, cell phone cams, and surveillance cams can provide a unique perspective on police encounters and, in most cases, are likely to help officers. But like those other devices, a camera mounted on your uniform or on your head has limitations that need to be understood and considered when evaluating the images, they record.

A camera doesn’t follow your eyes or see as they see

The camera does not follow the eyes of the wearer as the event occurs at the current level of development, a body camera is not an eye-tracker. That complex device can follow the movement of your eyes and superimpose on video small red circles that mark precisely where you are looking from one microsecond to the next.

A body camera photographs a broad scene but it can’t document where within that scene you are looking at any given instant. If you glance away from where the camera is concentrating, you may not see action within the camera frame that appears to be occurring ‘right before your eyes.’ There can be a huge disconnect between your field of view and the cameras. Later, someone reviewing what’s caught on camera and judging your actions could have a profoundly different sense of what happened then you had at the time it was occurring.

Camera speed differs from the speed of life

Because body cameras record at much higher speeds than a typical convenience store or correctional facility security cameras, it’s less likely that important details will be lost in the millisecond gaps between frames, as sometimes happens with those cruder devices. People who don’t understand the reactionary process won’t factor it in when viewing the footage. They’ll think the officer is keeping pace with the speed of the action as the camera records it. So, without knowledgeable input, they aren’t likely to understand how an officer can unintentionally end up placing rounds in a suspect’s back or firing additional shots after a threat has ended.

A camera may see better than you do in low light

The high-tech imaging of body cameras allows them to record with clarity in many low-light settings. When footage is screened later, it may actually be possible to see elements of the scene in sharper detail than you could at the time the camera was activated. On the other hand, cameras do not always deal well with lighting transitions. Going suddenly from bright to dim light or vice versa, a camera may briefly blank out images altogether.

Your body may block the view

How much of a scene a camera captures are highly dependent on where it’s positioned and where the action takes place. Depending on location and angle, a picture may be blocked by your own body parts, from your nose to your hands. Cameras are unable to capture a 360degree view of the situation that might be occurring. This thing cannot give us a true picture of the incident.  If you’re firing a gun or a Taser, for example, a camera on your chest may not record much more than your extended arms and hands. Or just blading your stance may obscure the camera’s view. Critical moments within a scenario that you can see maybe missed entirely by your body cam because of these dynamics, ultimately masking what a reviewer may need to see to make a fair judgment.

A camera only records in 2-D

Because cameras don’t record depth of field the third dimension that’s perceived by the human eye accurately judging distances on their footage can be difficult. Depending on the lens involved, cameras may compress distances between objects or make them appear closer than they really are, without a proper sense of distance a reviewer may misinterpret the level of threat an officer was facing. There are technical means for determining distances on 2-D recordings but these are not commonly known or accessed by most investigators.

One camera may not be enough

The more cameras there are recording a force event, the more opportunities there are likely to be to clarify uncertainties. The angle, the ambient lighting, and other elements will almost certainly vary from one officer’s perspective to another’s, and syncing the footage up will provide broader information for understanding the dynamics of what happened. What looks like an egregious action from one angle may seem perfectly justified from another.

Think of the analysis of plays in a football game. In resolving close calls, referees want to view the action from as many cameras as possible to fully understand what they’re seeing. Ideally, officers deserve the same consideration. The problem is that many times there is only one camera involved, compared to a dozen that may be consulted in a sporting event, and in that case, the limitations must be kept even firmer in mind.

A camera can never replace a thorough investigation

When officers oppose wearing cameras, civilians sometimes assume they fear “transparency.” But more often they are concerned that camera recordings will be given undue, if not exclusive, weight in judging their actions. A camera’s recording should never be regarded only as of the Truth about a controversial incident. It needs to be weighed and tested against witness testimony, forensics, the involved officer’s statement, and other elements of a fair, thorough, and impartial investigation that takes human factors into consideration. The limitations of body cams and others need to be fully understood and evaluated to maximize their effectiveness and to assure that they are not regarded as infallible ‘magic bullets’ by people who do not fully grasp the realities of force dynamics.

Officers do not turn “on” camera

  • A study of the New Orleans Police Department found nearly 100 incidents where police used force and were wearing body cameras but did not have them turned on.
  • Last September, two Vermont police officers shot and killed a man while wearing body cameras. Neither officer turned them on before the shooting; both were cleared of all wrongdoing.
  • Just before knocking a woman’s teeth out, two Daytona Beach, Florida, officers switched off their body cameras.
  • In September, police in Washington, D.C., fatally shot Terrence Sterling, an unarmed 31-year-old black man, after his motorcycle crashed into their car. But contrary to District policy, none of the officers at the scene activated their cameras until after the shooting. The footage the city released captures Sterling’s final moments, but the video begins over a minute after shots were fired. The case is being investigated by the U.S. Attorney’s Office. Now, D.C. officers are required to confirm with dispatchers that they’ve switched on their body cameras when responding to calls or interacting with the public.

Who Sells Body-Worn Camera Technology

Many police departments use body-worn cameras made by Axon (formerly Taser), which provides free cameras and sells data storage services. Other vendors include Aventura, Black Mamba, BrickHouse Security, Brimtek, COBAN, Data911, DEI, Digital Ally, FlyWIRE, Global Justice, GoPro, HauteSpot, HD Protech, Kustom Signals, L-3 Mobile-Vision, Law Systems, Marantz Professional, Martel, Motorola, Panasonic, Patrol Eyes, Paul Conway, Pinnacle, PRG, Primal USA, Utility Inc., PRO-VISION, Reveal Media, Safety Innovations, Safety Vision, Titan, Utility, VIEVU, VP360, WatchGuard, WOLFCOM, Zepcam, and Zetronix.

In addition to selling body cameras, some vendors also provide data storage for the footage. For example, body-worn camera suppliers OMG law enforcement give internal storage and SD card, and owns the company http://omg-solutions.com/ .

Stephon Clark, an African-American man, was killed by Sacramento police in his grandmother’s backyard, people protest against police action. Police initially said they thought Clark was armed. But after the shooting, the officers found no weapon on Clark, only an iPhone. The city police chief responding quickly to the protests by giving bodycam footage in an attempt to help the public, without notice what really happened. But footage cannot solve the matter.

Conclusion

Outrage over high profile incidents and a shift in public opinion has led police departments around the world to equip more officers with cameras and add de-escalation training. But no local, state or federal lawmakers have banned police from using unnecessary deadly force. Rather, lawmakers at all levels still allow police the maximum latitude to use deadly force that constitutional law permits. Indeed, a comparison with police shows that this leniency goes too far to protect police at the price of civilian deaths.

References

Anon., n.d. EFF. [Online]
Available at: https://www.eff.org/pages/body-worn-cameras
[Accessed October 18, 2017].

Anon., Sep 23, 2014. Force Science Institute. [Online]
Available at: https://www.policeone.com/police-products/body-cameras/articles/10-limitations-of-body-cams-you-need-to-know-for-your-protection-Y0Lhpm3vlPTsJ9OZ/

Hardy S, B. L. R. P. C. S. W. P. P.-H. S., 2017. Mental Health in Family Medicine. [Online]
Available at: http://www.mhfmjournal.com/old/open-access/the-feasibility-of-using-body-worn-cameras-in-an-inpatient-mental-health-setting.pdf

Ketchell, M., January 18, 2016. THE CONVERSATION. [Online]
Available at: http://theconversation.com/u-s-laws-protect-police-while-endangering-civilians-52737

PASTERNACK, A., n.d. FAST CCOMPANY. [Online]
Available at: https://www.fastcompany.com/3062837/it-fell-off-body-camera-problems

 

1063 Total Views 2 Views Today
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Leave a Reply

Contact Us

OMG Customer Care

Whatsapp

Singapore +65 8333 4466

Jakarta +62 8113 80221


email: sales@omg-solutions.com
or
Fill in the inquiry Form & we will get back to you within 2 Hrs

OMG Solutions Batam Office @ Harbourbay Ferry Terminal

OMG Solutions Batam Office @ Harbour-Bay-Ferry-Terminal

OMG Solutions has bought an office unit in Batam. Our formation of R&D Team in Batam is to provide incremental innovation to serve our new & existing customers better.
Visit Our Office in Batam @ Harbourbay Ferry Terminal.

Singapore Top 500 Enterprises 2018 & 2019

Singapore Top 500 Enterprises 2018

Camera Type


Page Categories

   Accessories - Body Worn Camera
   Articles - Body Worn Camera
    ↳ Law Enforcement Surveillance and Confidentiality in Asia
    ↳ Recognizing the Objection to Body-Worn Cameras by Workers
    ↳ Public Beliefs on Body-Worn Camera
    ↳ Body-Worn Camera Technological Innovation Throughout the Years
    ↳ Why Body-Worn Cameras help Law Administration?
    ↳ Impacts on Security Guards using Body-Worn Cameras
    ↳ Downsides of the Body-Worn Camera by Police Officers
    ↳ Privileges of using Police Body-Worn Camera
    ↳ Body-Worn Camera may Not be the Final Verdict
    ↳ Body-Worn Camera: Tactics That Will Help in Hospitals
    ↳ Introduction of Facial Recognition on Body-Worn Cameras
    ↳ Points to Note before Purchasing of a Body-Worn Camera
    ↳ Government's Network Protection with the Aid of a Body-Worn Camera
    ↳ Leverage Body cameras to ensure Employee Safety by Industries
    ↳ Introducing Schemes and Learning about Body-Worn Camera
    ↳ Drawbacks of Police Officers using Body-Worn Camera
    ↳ Reasons Body Worn Camera Footage might not Clear Things Up
    ↳ Procedures to Utilize Body-Worn Cameras
    ↳ Body-Worn Camera put to Use in Health Care Facilities
    ↳ Police Body Worn Cameras expected to Feature Facial Recognition
    ↳ Selecting the Proper Body-Worn Camera
    ↳ Secure Techniques Used by Government to Protect Body-Worn Camera Platform
    ↳ Benefits of Body Cameras by Industries
    ↳ Carrying Out a Body-Worn Camera Program and Classes
    ↳ Raising Concerns on Security and Privacy over Police Body-Worn Camera
    ↳ Body-Worn Camera could not Resolve All Situations
    ↳ Body-Worn Camera Usage Methods
    ↳ Advantages of Body-Worn Camera in Hospitals
    ↳ Promoting of Facial Recognition For Law Enforcement Officers Body-Worn Camera
    ↳ Deciding the Correct Body-Worn Camera
    ↳ Methods the Government can use to Protect the Network for Body-Worn Camera
    ↳ Utility of Body Worn Cameras by Industries
    ↳ Imposing Scheme for Body Worn Camera and Lesson Learned
    ↳ Increasing Safety Concerns and Confidentiality Regrading Police Body Worn Camera
    ↳ Why Body-Cam Footage Might Not Clear Things Up
    ↳ Guidelines for the Use of Body-Worn Cameras
    ↳ Body Worn Camera Use in Health Care Facilities
    ↳ Facial Recognition is Coming to Police Body-Worn Cameras
    ↳ Choosing the Right Body-Worn Camera
    ↳ Body-Worn Camera Secure Network for Government
    ↳ Use of Body-Worn Cameras by Industries
    ↳ Implementing a Body-Worn Camera Program Recommendations and Lessons Learned
    ↳ Police Body Worn Cameras Raise Security and Privacy Concerns
    ↳ How Police Officers Body Worn Camera Affects Privacy in Asia
    ↳ Employees Concern over Body-Worn Camera Usage
    ↳ Resident Insight of Body-Worn Cameras
    ↳ The Rise of Body-Worn Camera Technology
    ↳ Potential Benefits of Body Worn Camera for Law Enforcement
    ↳ Security Company - How Effects is Police Body Worn Cameras
    ↳ Despite the Limitations, Police Body Cameras are Still Popular
   Body Worn Camera
    ↳ BWC080-4G - Secure AES256 - 4G Body Worn Camera for Government Agencies
    ↳ BWC075 - OMG World Smallest Mini Police Body Worn Camera
    ↳ BWC078 - OMG OTG USB Android and WIFI Smartphone Mini Bullet Body Helmet Camera
    ↳ BWC062 - OMG Headlight Body Worn Camera
    ↳ BWC073-4GFR - OMG Police Body Worn Camera - 4G Live Stream with Facial Recognition Design for Airport Security Staff
    ↳ BWC074 - Mini Light weight Body Worn Camera with Super Video Compression – 20-25 Hrs for 32GB [No LCD Screen]
    ↳ BWC076 - OMG Police Body Worn Camera with Bullet Head-set for Paramedics
    ↳ BWC065 - Helmet Camera 4G WIFI Camera Head Safety Camera
    ↳ BWC072 - Outdoor Activities Waterproof Body Worn Helmet Headset Camera - WIFI Waterproof
    ↳ BWC058-4G - Mini WIFI/GPS/3G/4G Body Worn Camera - Facial Recognition
    ↳ BWC058 - Mini Body Worn Camera - Super Video Compression - 20-25 Hrs for 32GB
    ↳ BWC061 - OMG Long Hours [16 Hrs] Recording Body Worn Camera
    ↳ BWC059 - Secure Mini Body Worn Camera with Encryption [No LCD Screen]
    ↳ Mini Body Worn Camera with External Memory (BWC055)
    ↳ Wearable Headset Body Worn Camera (BWC056)
    ↳ Rotatable lens Body Worn Camera Camera (BWC057)
    ↳ CCD Button Camera, HD 1920*1080 MOV, TF 64G, H.264, Magnetic ring induction, CCD 700TVL Camera (BWC054)
    ↳ Light Weight WIFI Law Enforcement Body Worn Camera, Video 1728*1296 30fps, H.264, 940NM Nightvision (BWC052)
    ↳ BWC043 – Affordable Police Body Worn Camera
    ↳ Badge Body Worn Camera (BWC041)
    ↳ OMG Mini Body Worn Camera, 2K Video (SPY195)
    ↳ WIFI/GPS/3G/4G Body Worn Camera (BWC011)
    ↳ WIFI/4G/LTE/GPS 1080P HD Headlight Helmet Camera (BWC009)
    ↳ OMG 4G Wireless Body Camera (BWC004-4G)
    ↳ BWC004 - Police Body Worn Camera
    ↳ Mini Body Worn Camera (BWC003)
    ↳ Mini Wireless WIFI Spy Hidden Pinhole Camera - up to 15 hrs Recording (SPY032)
    ↳ OMG Wearable Button Camera, Motion Activated Video Recorder (SPY045B)
   Uncategorized - Body Worn Camera
    ↳ BWC071 - Extra Mini Body Worn Camera
    ↳ BWC066 - Police Body Camera Head Bullet Cam for Helmet
    ↳ Secure Mini Body Worn Camera with Encryption [With LCD Screen] (BWC060)
    ↳ Lock Clip (BWA010)
    ↳ Mini HD Body Worn Police Camera, 12MP OV2710 140 Degree Camera, H.264 MOV, 1080P, TF Max 128G, Long Time Work (BWC053)
    ↳ Dual Lens Ambarella A7 Police Body Worn Camera with 7000mah Battery, Police Camera (BWC051)
    ↳ OMG Wifi Mini Wearable Sports Action Helmet Camera (BWC049)
    ↳ Mini Spy Camera - Hidden Pocket Pen Camera 170 Degree Wide Angle Lens (SPY018)
    ↳ OMG Affordable 4G Body Worn Camera (BWC047)
    ↳ Smart Glasses Body Worn Camera (BWC042)
    ↳ Videos
    ↳ BWC040 - Affordable HD Body Worn Camera
    ↳ Mini Police Body Worn Camera, 1296p, 170Deg, 12 Hours, GPS, Night Visual (BWC010)
    ↳ Removable Battery - Body Worn Camera (BWC037)
    ↳ Body Worn Camera - 3G, 4G, Wi-Fi, Live streaming, Remote control live, Bluetooth, Mobile APP(IOS+Android), 8hrs continuous recording, touch slide control. (BWC035)
    ↳ Body Worn Camera - Wifi Body Camera (BWC034)
    ↳ Body Worn Camera - Novatek 96650 chipset , Built-in storage card (BWC033)
    ↳ Body Worn Camera, Wireless Remote Control (BWC032)
    ↳ Body Worn Camera - Ambarella A7LA50 chipset, 140Degree Wide angle, 128GB Max storage, GPS built-in (BWC031)
    ↳ Body Worn Camera - Ambarella A7LA50 chipset, 140Degree Wide angle, 128GB Max storage, GPS built-in (BWC030)
    ↳ Body Worn Camera - Ambarella A7LA50 chipset, 170Degree Wide angle, 128GB Max storage, 12+hours long time recording (BWC029)
    ↳ Body Worn Camera - Ambarella A7LA50 chipset , 170Degree Wide angle, 128GB Max storage, Removable battery type (BWC028)
    ↳ Body Worn Camera - Ambarella A7LA50 chipset , 170Degree Wide angle , 128GB Max storage , Dual Lens with external button lens (BWC027)
    ↳ Body Worn Camera - Ambarella A7LA50 chipset ,170 Degree Wide angle , 128GB Max storage (BWC026)
    ↳ Body Worn Camera - Novatek 96650 chipset (BWC025)
    ↳ Body Worn Camera - Two replaceable 2500mAh batteries (BWC024)
    ↳ Body Worn Camera - Novatek 96650 chipset (BWC023)
    ↳ Body Worn Camera - Built-in GPS, GPS + Radio Cable + Dual Lens Optional (BWC022)
    ↳ Body Worn Camera External SD Card (BWC021)
    ↳ Body Worn Camera - Auto night vision, adjustable focus while recording, Design For Turkish Government (BWC020)
    ↳ OMG 4G Body Worn Camera (BWC012)
    ↳ Removable Battery GPS Body Worn Police Camera [140deg] (BWC006)
    ↳ OMG 12 Ports Body Worn Camera Docking Station (BWC001)
    ↳ Hidden Mini Spy Video Camera (SPY006)
    ↳ Hidden Spy Pocket Pen Video Camera (SPY009)
    ↳ Button Camera (SPY031)
    ↳ WIFI Pen Camera DVR, P2P, IP, 1080P Video recorder, App Control (SPY086)
    ↳ WIFI Meeting Recording Pen, H.264,1080p, Motion Detection, SD Card Max 128G (SPY091)
    ↳ Products
    ↳ Digital Voice & Video Recorder, Video 1080p, Voice 512kbps, 180 Deg Rotation (SPY106)
    ↳ WIFI Portable Wearable Security 12MP Camera, 1296P, H.264, App control (SPY084)
    ↳ Body Worn Camera / Digital Evidence Management (BWC008)
    ↳ Jobs Listing

Latest News